Together, we can make a Difference

Cross-Border

The Cross-Border working group champions UK and global initiatives that drive the interconnectivity of international payment systems and embrace innovative technologies, fostering a more efficient and inclusive cross-border ecosystem that supports growing digital economies.

Supported by

An industry-led assessment of the FSB’s cross-border payment targets, examining where progress is falling short, why global measures can obscure end-user outcomes, and how the framework should evolve, produced by The Payments Association’s Cross-Border Working Group in collaboration with Payall.

The FSB’s targets established a common framework for improving the cost, speed, access and transparency of cross-border payments. Progress, however, should ultimately be judged by the experience of the end user.

This report finds that global averages can conceal poor outcomes in individual corridors, while improvements to payment infrastructure do not necessarily translate into faster, cheaper or more accessible payments. The framework also leaves security outside the formal target structure despite its growing importance.

Key findings

Cost: Global averages hide expensive corridors

No cost KPI has reached the 1% target, and 18.3% of monitored corridors still exceed the 3% cap. A falling global average can coexist with stagnant costs in the corridors where cost matters most.

Speed: Fast to the bank is not fast to the customer

Around 89% of SWIFT payments reach the recipient’s bank within an hour, but only around 60% reach the customer’s account in that time. The delay sits in the final leg: compliance checks, batch processing, and operating hours, and the target explicitly carves compliance out. In many cases, predictability is more important than speed.

Access: Having an account is not the same as having access

Progress is tracked through account ownership, which is a precondition for access rather than a measure of it. The unbanked are absent from the KPI. The target is satisfied by a single option, however slow or expensive. It also ignores whether PSPs can access payment systems, which determines whether options exist in the first place.

Transparency: A disclosure checklist is not transparency

The KPI checks only whether cost and speed are disclosed at initiation. Only 62.9% of cost-transparent providers also disclose speed. Status tracking, delays and failures go unmeasured.

Safety: Payment risk is missing from the targets

Faster, cheaper and more accessible payments can also increase exposure to fraud and other risks. Yet the current framework does not explicitly measure safety, making it difficult to assess whether gains in cost, speed and access are being achieved without increasing risk.

Why should I join a working group?

The Payments Association’s working groups comprise industry experts from across the payments chain, who share the mission of driving industry change to shape the future payments landscape and improve the industry on behalf of members of the association.

Being a member of one of The Payments Association’s working groups comes with a host of benefits:

  • You will get exclusive access to meetings with industry experts.
  • The opportunity to build your network with the leading figures from across the payments industry.
  • Invitations to exclusive events from The Payments Association, such as the Working Group AGM at the annual PAY360 conference.
  • The opportunity to actively help deliver the working group outputs.


In addition, committee members will receive:

  • An invitation to an annual in-person meeting.
  • The opportunity to feature your headshot and company logo on selected outputs and our website.
  • The opportunity to contribute and network in our monthly meetings.


All working group members are representatives of organisations with The Payments Association membership.

Strategy and approach

Our mission

Masha Cilliers headshot

“The Cross-Border Working Group aims to foster a collaborative approach when providing thought leadership to TPA membership and gathering feedback for industry stakeholders that challenges the regulatory evolution of international payments. We want to ensure that the international payments framework accounts for the broad range of current and future requirements of its local and international users and encourages healthy competition between a wide range of providers.”

Masha Cilliers, The Payments Association Ambassador & Cross-Border Working Group Lead

Team members

Alan Marquard

Mastercard
Fellow and Executive Vice President
Anupam Bansal headshot

Anupam Bansal

Oxygen Consultancy
Managing Director
Chris Partridge headshot

Chris Partridge

Crown Agents Bank
Head of Banks and NFBIs

David Swann

Corpay
Global Director of Partnerships
Erhan Tetik headshot

Erhan Tetik

Bank of London
Commercial Director

Gary Palmer

Payall
CEO

Hims Joshi

Lloyds
Managing Director, Head, Strategic Partnerships

Lee McNab

NatWest
Head of Payments Strategy & Partnerships
Masha Cilliers headshot

Masha Cilliers

The Payments Association
Ambassador & Cross Border Working Group Lead

Matt Williamson

Endava
SVP & Industry Principal

Murthy Maddali

Techwave
UK Managing Director
Natalie Lewis

Natalie Lewis

Travers Smith
Head of Fintech, Market Infrastructure and Payments & Digital Currencies Working Group Mentor

Noyan Nihat

Cardaq
Director, Inclusion Working Group Mentor
Robin Anderson headshot

Robin Anderson

Tribe Payments
Chief Revenue Officer

Somya Patnaik

ACI Worldwide
Global Solutions Leader, Real-Time Payments
Yoav Ash headshot

Yoav Ash

Thought Machine
Head of Payments Product

Members involved

Outputs

The cross-border working group published a whitepaper providing 10 key takeaways to improve the future of cross-border payments, citing a series of interviews with experts and a survey of 100+ industry professionals. 

Cross-border payments are perceived as inherently high risk due to reliance on manual process and lack of transparency among the players. This has created knock on effects (slow, expensive and limited services) for senders and recipients of cross-border payments; a complicated and burdensome regulatory environment that fails significantly in meeting its goals to stop international money laundering and other nefarious acts; and, ultimately, a lack of competition and innovation — continuing the cycle.   

The Cross–border Working Group published a short report highlighting the key challenges, barriers and complexities our members face when delivering and receiving cross-border payments. 

The Cross-border working group co-hosted a Global Payments Forum meeting with IIF and EPA Asia, which examined the role of CBDCs in disrupting cross-border payments.

In this episode of the Insights podcast, Tony Craddock, Director General of the Payments Association, welcomes Gary Palmer, CEO and Chairman of Payall, for a focused discussion on the evolution and challenges of cross-border payments. With decades of experience, Palmer offers a critical analysis of why this sector, crucial to the global economy, has seen limited technological advancement and outlines the transformative changes on the horizon.

February 2024
November 2024

Recent related articles

Get in touch

Interested in joining our Cross-Border Working Group?

Please fill out the form to indicate your interest in receiving more information about The Payments Association’s Cross-border Working Group. A member of our Project Team will be in touch with you shortly.

Membership

Merchant Community Membership

Are you a member of The Payments Association?

Member benefits include free tickets, discounts to more tickets, elevated brand visibility and more. Sign in to book tickets and find out more.