Our latest insights

USDC Vs. USDT: Which Stablecoin Is Better For Cross-Border Settlements?

Share this post

Arf
USDC Vs. USDT: Which Stablecoin Is Better For Cross-Border Settlements?

USDC and USDT are currently the world’s leading stablecoins, with a combined share of more than 80% of the stablecoin market. Both are backed by a proportionally 1:1 amount of traditional assets like cash, making the price of a stablecoin stay pegged to $1.

Since traditional finance hasn’t found a solution to real-time and compliant cross-border payments yet, more money service businesses (MSBs) are turning to using stablecoins in such transactions every passing day. However, most of them are conducted off-the-books, relying on the trust each party has for the other. This raises legitimate security concerns for not only MSBs on both ends but also for the health of the global finance industry.

We’ve put together the features of USDC and USDT, the most popular stablecoins in the world, to provide a complete picture for MSBs looking for a digital asset to utilize.

Market Size

USDC and USDT currently dominate the stablecoin market, with a combined share of more than 80%.

stablecoins
Source: Total Stablecoin Supply, The Block Crypto (9 May 2022)

World’s first stablecoin, Tether (USDT), is the biggest stablecoin with a $79.4 billion market capitalization as of May ’22. USD Coin (USDC) makes the second biggest one, with a market capitalization worth $49.4 billion as of May ‘22.

How are they backed?

The report published by Centre in October 2021 shows that 100% of USDC reserves are made up of cash and cash equivalents. The higher proportion of cash and cash equivalents indicates its ability to fund large-scale USDC redemptions in case of a crisis.

On the other hand, Tether was fined $41 million for claiming its digital tokens were fully backed by fiat currencies in 2021, creating a worldwide distrust to the honesty and transparency of the issuer. After endless allegations, Tether published a report in December 2021, revealing that 84% of its assets are in cash, cash equivalents, short-term deposits, and commercial papers.

How are they audited?

As of April 2022, the global stablecoin market reached over $181 billion in size. Given their potentially disruptive impact, regular audits of stablecoins by independent auditors have vital importance.

USDT is currently audited irregularly, which raises questions about its transparency. On the other hand, USDC is audited once a month by a Top 5, TIER1 accounting firm to attest that it is 100% backed.

USDC vs. USDT

We’ve put together a table with the key differences between USDC and USDT:

USDC USDT
Creator Centre Consortium (by Circle) Tether Limited
Year Established 2018 2014
Price Peg 1 USDC : 1 USD 1 USDT : 1 USD
Market cap (May’22) $49.4 Billion $79.4 Billion
Backing 100% cash & cash equivalents 1:1 by liquid debt assets, treasuries, and some cash
Audit Frequency Monthly Irregular
Price Risk / Risk of Losing 1:1 Peg Zero as it’s 100% redeemable due to its always liquid type of backing. Non-zero price risk, but generally it stays very close to $1 because it can be redeemed (though limited to liquid assets in short term)

For reference, USDT has stayed within a few % of $1 during the UST/LUNA crash, and it’s rumored that $1b+ is successfully redeemed.

Regulatory Status This type of stablecoins (100% redeemable) is what current drafts of regulations (especially US) are looking to license, as a first step.

They are treated as e-money in many jurisdictions, such as the UK.

Unclear
Accounting Reliable asset due to its zero price risk, regulatory status and transparent audit reports. Not reliable due to price risk, opaque backing and unclear regulatory status.

USDC proves to be a more reliable option

Both USDC and USDT are pegged to the USD, and both are very popular. Although USDT is the biggest stablecoin yet, USDC is rapidly catching up, with a growth rate of 5x in the past 12 months. USDC is fully backed by cash and short-dated U.S. government obligations. Considering that USDC is a much safer store of value, this rapid increase is no coincidence.

In terms of many aspects, including how it was backed and audited and regulatory status, USDC proves to be a more reliable asset for Money Service Businesses.

Fully compliant, real-time cross-border payments and treasury management is possible.

Arf only works with attested, audited, and fiat-backed stablecoins of 1:1 peg like USDC. By leveraging reliable stablecoins, Arf enables MSBs to achieve fully compliant and real-time fiat-to-fiat cross-border payments. 

Want to learn more? Get in touch with us.

More To Explore

Login or Register

Don't have an account?

Are you part of the Payments Association community?

Not yet set up your login for the Payments Association Community Platform? Set it up now

Set up a free account for instant access to our content

You don’t need to be an Payments Association member to view the majority of our content. Simply enter your details below once to set up your login details and get access to our library of whitepapers, podcasts, consultation papers, webinars and more.

First Name*
Last Name*
Company Name*
Job Title*
Username*
Business Email Address*
Password*
Confirm Password*
Agreement*
The Payments Association exist to help drive the industry forward. As such the Payments Association may contact you about any future content or events that we think you may have a legitimate interest in. We will store your information securely and will never share your details with third parties other than the relevant resource(s) sponsor(s)/curator(s). You may opt out at any time. By clicking register you are agreeing to the terms of our Privacy Policy.

← back